Terahertz Communications
Introduction to Terahertz Communications
Terahertz (THz) communications represents one of the most promising frontiers in wireless technology, exploiting the largely unused electromagnetic spectrum between 0.1 and 10 THz. This frequency range, often called the "terahertz gap," sits between microwave and infrared frequencies, offering unprecedented bandwidth potential for next-generation communication systems. While technically challenging due to atmospheric absorption and device limitations, terahertz technology promises data rates measured in terabits per second, making it ideal for applications ranging from wireless data centers to chip-to-chip communications.
The terahertz spectrum has historically been underutilized due to technological constraints in both generating and detecting these waves. However, recent advances in semiconductor technology, photonics, and nano-fabrication have made practical terahertz systems increasingly viable. Beyond communications, terahertz technology enables unique sensing and imaging capabilities due to the distinctive spectral signatures of many materials in this frequency range, opening applications in security screening, medical diagnostics, and quality control.
The Terahertz Spectrum Gap
The terahertz frequency range occupies a unique position in the electromagnetic spectrum, corresponding to wavelengths from 3 millimeters down to 30 micrometers. This region represents a transition zone where traditional electronic approaches from lower frequencies and photonic techniques from optical frequencies converge. The spectrum gap exists because conventional electronic devices struggle to operate efficiently above several hundred gigahertz, while photonic devices designed for infrared and visible light face challenges scaling down to lower frequencies.
The enormous bandwidth available in the terahertz region—potentially tens of gigahertz for individual channels—enables communication systems with data rates far exceeding what is possible with current millimeter-wave 5G technology. International regulatory bodies are beginning to allocate portions of the terahertz spectrum for communications use, particularly focusing on bands with lower atmospheric absorption for practical wireless links. These allocations recognize both the tremendous capacity potential and the inherently short-range nature of most terahertz wireless systems.
Terahertz Generation Methods
Generating terahertz radiation requires specialized techniques that bridge the gap between electronics and photonics. Electronic approaches extend traditional microwave techniques to higher frequencies using advanced semiconductor devices. Frequency multiplication chains use harmonic generators to boost millimeter-wave signals into the low terahertz range, though efficiency decreases rapidly with increasing multiplication factors. High-electron-mobility transistors (HEMTs) and heterojunction bipolar transistors (HBTs) can achieve fundamental oscillation up to several hundred gigahertz, representing the upper limit of purely electronic generation.
Photonic generation techniques leverage optical methods to produce terahertz radiation. Photomixing combines two laser sources with slightly different wavelengths on a photoconductive antenna, generating terahertz radiation at the beat frequency. This approach offers broad tunability and can reach higher frequencies than electronic methods. Quantum cascade lasers (QCLs) represent another photonic approach, using intersubband transitions in semiconductor heterostructures to directly emit terahertz radiation. These compact solid-state sources have advanced significantly, achieving room-temperature operation in some frequency ranges and milliwatt-level output powers.
Ultrafast optical techniques provide another generation pathway, using femtosecond laser pulses to excite photoconductive switches or generate terahertz pulses through nonlinear optical processes in crystals. While primarily used in spectroscopy and imaging applications, these methods demonstrate the broadband nature of terahertz radiation and have influenced the development of communication-oriented sources. Vacuum electronic devices, including backward-wave oscillators and extended interaction oscillators, can also generate terahertz radiation with relatively high power levels, though they tend to be bulkier and more expensive than solid-state alternatives.
Terahertz Detection Techniques
Detecting terahertz radiation presents challenges comparable to generation, requiring devices that can respond to these high-frequency electromagnetic waves. Direct detection approaches use semiconductor devices that convert terahertz radiation directly to electrical signals. Schottky barrier diodes extend to several terahertz with proper design, offering room-temperature operation and video-rate detection speeds. Hot-electron bolometers provide extremely sensitive detection by measuring the resistance change in a superconducting or semiconductor element heated by incident terahertz radiation, though they typically require cryogenic cooling for optimal performance.
Field-effect transistors, particularly those based on high-mobility semiconductors like graphene or III-V compounds, can detect terahertz radiation through plasmonic effects or direct rectification. These detectors offer the potential for integration into standard semiconductor processes and array configurations for imaging applications. Photonic detection methods include electro-optic sampling, where terahertz fields modulate optical properties of nonlinear crystals that are then probed with ultrafast lasers, providing phase-sensitive detection with excellent temporal resolution.
For communication applications, coherent detection systems that preserve both amplitude and phase information offer significant advantages in sensitivity and spectral efficiency. Heterodyne and homodyne receivers mix the incoming terahertz signal with a local oscillator to down-convert to intermediate frequencies where conventional signal processing techniques apply. These coherent systems enable advanced modulation formats and multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) techniques, maximizing the information capacity of terahertz channels.
Propagation Characteristics at THz Frequencies
Terahertz wave propagation exhibits unique characteristics that fundamentally shape system design and application domains. Atmospheric absorption represents the most significant propagation challenge, with water vapor and oxygen molecules creating strong absorption peaks throughout the terahertz spectrum. These absorption features create alternating windows and peaks, with relatively transparent regions around 0.3, 0.35, 0.41, 0.67, and 0.85 THz for ground-level communications. The atmospheric absorption increases dramatically above 1 THz, effectively limiting long-distance outdoor communications to lower terahertz frequencies.
Free-space path loss increases with the square of frequency, making terahertz links inherently more challenging than microwave systems at equivalent distances. However, the small wavelengths enable highly directive antennas in compact form factors, partially compensating for this increased path loss through high antenna gains. Terahertz waves exhibit quasi-optical propagation behavior, following straight-line paths with minimal diffraction around obstacles due to the short wavelengths, which necessitates line-of-sight links for most applications.
Material interactions at terahertz frequencies differ substantially from those at lower frequencies. Many materials that are opaque to visible light transmit terahertz radiation, while others show strong absorption or dispersion. These properties enable unique sensing applications but also affect indoor propagation, where walls, furniture, and building materials create complex multipath environments. Rain, fog, and dust can cause significant additional attenuation, particularly affecting outdoor links and limiting the practical range of terahertz communication systems.
Terahertz Antennas and Arrays
Antenna design for terahertz frequencies combines principles from microwave engineering and optics, resulting in structures that bridge conventional radio antennas and photonic devices. The small wavelengths—ranging from millimeters to tens of micrometers—enable high-gain antennas in extremely compact form factors. Planar antennas fabricated using photolithographic techniques include dipoles, patches, slots, and bow-ties integrated directly with semiconductor devices. These antennas often incorporate matching networks and lens coupling to improve radiation efficiency and beam control.
Horn antennas and reflector systems provide high directivity for point-to-point links, with designs optimized for the quasi-optical nature of terahertz propagation. Silicon and polymer lenses focus terahertz beams and can be integrated with on-chip antenna structures, creating compact transceiver modules. Dielectric resonator antennas offer an alternative approach with good radiation efficiency and relatively simple fabrication. Advanced designs incorporate metamaterials and frequency-selective surfaces to control radiation patterns and bandwidth.
Phased arrays and leaky-wave antennas enable beam steering without mechanical mechanisms, crucial for establishing and maintaining links in mobile or reconfigurable systems. These arrays can implement spatial multiplexing and beamforming techniques that enhance channel capacity and link reliability. The small wavelength allows dense packing of array elements, enabling many-element arrays in chip-scale implementations. However, feeding networks and phase control at terahertz frequencies present significant design challenges, particularly regarding losses and manufacturability.
Atmospheric Absorption and Propagation Windows
Atmospheric absorption fundamentally determines the viable frequency bands and link distances for terahertz communications. Water vapor molecules exhibit numerous rotational resonance lines throughout the terahertz spectrum, creating absorption peaks that can exceed 100 dB/km at certain frequencies. Oxygen absorption adds additional features, particularly above 100 GHz. Between these absorption peaks lie transmission windows where atmospheric attenuation is relatively low—though still substantially higher than at microwave frequencies.
The most commonly exploited propagation windows for outdoor terahertz communications occur at frequencies where absorption dips below 10-20 dB/km under standard atmospheric conditions. These windows shift and vary with altitude, humidity, temperature, and pressure, requiring adaptive system designs for reliable operation across different environments. Space communications and very high altitude platform systems can access higher terahertz frequencies where atmospheric absorption becomes negligible, enabling even greater bandwidths and data rates.
For indoor and short-range applications, atmospheric absorption matters less than material properties and multipath propagation. Dry environments like data centers or controlled laboratory settings allow operation at absorption peaks that would be impractical outdoors. The frequency-dependent absorption creates opportunities for adaptive systems that select operating frequencies based on link distance, atmospheric conditions, and interference environment, optimizing performance dynamically.
Ultra-High Data Rates and Modulation
The enormous bandwidth available at terahertz frequencies enables communication data rates measured in hundreds of gigabits to multiple terabits per second—orders of magnitude beyond current wireless systems. Single-carrier systems can occupy multi-gigahertz bandwidths, while multi-carrier approaches like orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) efficiently utilize available spectrum across propagation windows. These ultra-wideband signals require careful consideration of dispersion, both in the atmosphere and in system components, which can cause inter-symbol interference and signal distortion.
Advanced modulation formats maximize spectral efficiency within the available bandwidth. Amplitude and phase modulation schemes, including high-order quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM), require precise control of both terahertz carrier generation and detection. Coherent communication systems preserve phase information, enabling these sophisticated modulation formats and approaching the theoretical Shannon capacity limits of terahertz channels. However, phase noise in terahertz sources and frequency instabilities present significant challenges, requiring advanced signal processing and tracking algorithms.
Orbital angular momentum (OAM) multiplexing and other spatial multiplexing techniques offer pathways to further increase channel capacity by utilizing multiple orthogonal modes on the same frequency. The short wavelengths at terahertz frequencies enable practical implementation of these techniques with compact antenna arrays. Polarization multiplexing doubles capacity by transmitting independent data streams on orthogonal polarizations. Combined with spatial multiplexing through MIMO systems, these techniques push terahertz communication systems toward the multi-terabit data rates needed for next-generation applications.
Short-Range THz Communication Systems
The high atmospheric absorption and propagation characteristics of terahertz waves naturally suit short-range communication applications where extreme bandwidth is needed within confined spaces. Wireless data centers represent a compelling use case, where terahertz links could replace fiber-optic cables for rack-to-rack or even server-to-server communications, providing reconfigurable connectivity with terabit-scale bandwidth. The short range—typically meters to tens of meters—aligns well with data center geometry while the high capacity supports bandwidth-intensive applications like distributed computing and real-time data analytics.
Kiosk downloading scenarios leverage terahertz communications for ultra-fast content transfer, enabling users to download movies, datasets, or software updates in seconds. These applications tolerate the line-of-sight requirement and limited range, focusing instead on maximizing throughput during brief connection periods. Wireless virtual reality and augmented reality systems represent another natural application, where terahertz links provide the multi-gigabit wireless connectivity needed for untethered headsets receiving high-resolution video streams with minimal latency.
Indoor wireless local area networks (WLANs) operating in the terahertz band could deliver unprecedented wireless speeds to stationary or slowly moving users, complementing rather than replacing lower-frequency systems that provide better coverage and mobility. Backhaul links for dense small-cell networks in millimeter-wave 5G and future 6G systems could use terahertz frequencies to aggregate traffic from multiple access points, providing the high-capacity wireless backhaul needed for ultra-dense network deployments.
Terahertz Integrated Circuits
Integrated circuit technology for terahertz frequencies represents a critical enabling technology, combining active devices, antennas, and signal processing on single chips. Silicon-based processes, including CMOS and silicon-germanium (SiGe) BiCMOS, have been pushed to operate well into the terahertz range, with transistors achieving cutoff frequencies above 500 GHz. These silicon technologies offer the advantages of mature manufacturing, low cost, and integration with digital signal processing circuitry, though they face fundamental physical limitations as frequencies increase.
III-V semiconductor technologies, particularly those based on indium phosphide (InP) and gallium arsenide (GaAs), provide superior high-frequency performance with transistors reaching terahertz cutoff frequencies. Indium gallium arsenide (InGaAs) high-electron-mobility transistors demonstrate excellent noise figures and gain at terahertz frequencies, making them preferred for sensitive receiver applications. Heterojunction bipolar transistors in InP technology achieve power levels and efficiency suitable for transmitter applications while maintaining adequate frequency performance.
Antenna-in-package and system-in-package approaches integrate antennas, RF frontends, and baseband processing in multi-chip modules optimized for terahertz operation. These integrated solutions address the challenge of connecting discrete components at frequencies where even short interconnects introduce significant losses and parasitics. Wafer-scale integration techniques enable complete terahertz transceivers with integrated antennas fabricated in single manufacturing processes, dramatically reducing size and cost while improving performance through elimination of package parasitics and bond wire inductances.
Terahertz Imaging Applications
Terahertz imaging exploits the unique interaction of terahertz radiation with materials to create images based on transmission, reflection, or emission characteristics. Unlike X-rays, terahertz radiation is non-ionizing and safe for biological tissues, while still penetrating many optically opaque materials like clothing, packaging, and building materials. Time-domain terahertz imaging systems use ultrashort pulses to measure both amplitude and phase, enabling three-dimensional reconstruction and spectroscopic identification of materials based on their terahertz absorption and dispersion signatures.
Continuous-wave terahertz imaging systems offer simpler hardware and faster imaging rates, trading some spectral information for improved real-time performance. Focal plane arrays of terahertz detectors enable video-rate imaging without mechanical scanning, though fabricating large detector arrays at terahertz frequencies remains challenging. Passive imaging systems detect naturally occurring terahertz radiation emitted by objects at different temperatures, similar to infrared thermal imaging but at longer wavelengths that penetrate clothing and some building materials.
Synthetic aperture techniques and computational imaging methods enhance resolution beyond the diffraction limit imposed by terahertz wavelengths. Near-field imaging with subwavelength apertures or structured illumination provides resolution approaching that of optical microscopy in certain configurations. These imaging capabilities complement communication applications, with many technological developments benefiting both domains, particularly in source and detector development, beam steering, and signal processing.
Security Screening Applications
Security screening represents one of the most developed applications of terahertz technology, leveraging the ability of terahertz waves to penetrate clothing while being reflected by metals, explosives, and other materials of security interest. Terahertz imaging systems deployed at airports and secure facilities can detect concealed weapons, explosives, and contraband without physical contact or ionizing radiation exposure. The spectroscopic capabilities of terahertz systems enable identification of specific materials based on their unique spectral signatures, distinguishing actual threats from benign objects.
Stand-off detection systems operate at distances of several meters, imaging subjects as they walk through screening portals at natural pace. These systems must balance image quality, scanning speed, privacy concerns, and detection sensitivity. Active illumination with terahertz sources provides controlled imaging conditions, while passive systems that detect ambient and body-temperature terahertz radiation offer covert detection capabilities. Advanced signal processing and machine learning algorithms analyze terahertz images to automatically identify potential threats, reducing operator workload and improving detection consistency.
Package and mail screening systems use terahertz transmission imaging to inspect contents without opening containers. These systems can identify suspicious materials, verify contents match shipping manifests, and detect concealed compartments. The non-destructive nature of terahertz inspection makes it ideal for screening valuable or sensitive items. Combined with automated handling systems, terahertz screening can inspect high volumes of packages with minimal delay, supporting both security and logistics applications.
Medical Imaging Potential
Medical imaging with terahertz radiation offers unique capabilities for diagnosing and monitoring various conditions. Terahertz waves are particularly sensitive to water content and can distinguish between healthy and diseased tissues based on differences in hydration, structure, and composition. Skin cancer detection shows particular promise, as terahertz imaging can differentiate between normal skin, basal cell carcinoma, and other lesions with good sensitivity and specificity. The non-ionizing nature of terahertz radiation makes it safe for repeated examinations and screening applications.
Dental imaging applications use terahertz radiation to detect caries, cracks, and defects in teeth and dental restorations. The dielectric properties of tooth enamel, dentin, and decay differ significantly at terahertz frequencies, enabling early detection of dental problems before they become visible through conventional examination. Burn wound assessment with terahertz imaging can determine burn depth and monitor healing, potentially improving treatment decisions and outcomes for burn patients.
Pharmaceutical applications include tablet coating inspection, where terahertz imaging non-destructively measures coating thickness and uniformity. Time-domain terahertz spectroscopy can identify and quantify active pharmaceutical ingredients, detect counterfeit drugs, and monitor manufacturing quality. Intraoperative guidance systems using terahertz imaging could help surgeons distinguish tumor margins from healthy tissue during cancer surgery, though significant development remains needed to create practical clinical instruments. The translation of terahertz imaging to routine medical use faces challenges including system cost, size, imaging speed, and integration with clinical workflows.
Wireless Data Centers
Wireless data centers represent a transformative application of terahertz communications, potentially replacing thousands of fiber-optic cables with reconfigurable wireless links operating at terabit-scale data rates. Traditional data center networks use fixed fiber connections between servers, switches, and storage systems, creating cable management challenges and limiting flexibility when workloads change or equipment is reconfigured. Terahertz wireless links could dynamically establish connections on demand, optimizing network topology for current workload patterns and eliminating physical cable constraints.
The short-range, high-bandwidth characteristics of terahertz communications align perfectly with data center requirements. Rack-to-rack distances typically measure just a few meters, well within terahertz link budgets even accounting for atmospheric absorption and component losses. The controlled indoor environment of data centers eliminates weather-related propagation variability and enables precise link planning. Beamforming and beam steering techniques could create point-to-point links that minimize interference and maximize spatial reuse, allowing many simultaneous terahertz links within the same data center space.
Hybrid architectures combining fiber-optic cables for stable baseline connectivity with terahertz wireless for dynamic traffic demands may emerge as practical deployment models. These systems could maintain critical communications on fiber while using terahertz links to handle traffic bursts, support temporary computing clusters, or provide failover paths for robustness. Management and orchestration systems would need to coordinate radio resource allocation, beam steering, and handover between access points to maintain the ultra-high reliability required for data center operations. Power consumption, thermal management, and electromagnetic compatibility in dense terahertz transceiver deployments present significant engineering challenges for practical implementation.
Chip-to-Chip Communications
Chip-to-chip and board-to-board communications using terahertz frequencies address the growing interconnect bottleneck in high-performance computing systems. As processor speeds increase and multi-chip modules become more prevalent, the bandwidth and latency of inter-chip communications increasingly limit overall system performance. Electrical interconnects face fundamental physical constraints on bandwidth and power consumption, while optical interconnects, though high-bandwidth, require complex interfaces and precise alignment. Terahertz wireless interconnects could provide a middle ground, offering very high bandwidth without the constraints of physical contacts or optical alignment.
On-chip antennas integrated directly in processor or memory chips could transmit and receive terahertz signals across air gaps of just millimeters to centimeters. These short distances enable very high data rates even with modest transmit powers, while the dielectric environment between chips can be carefully controlled to optimize propagation. Beamforming with small antenna arrays ensures that signals reach intended receivers with minimal crosstalk to other chips, enabling simultaneous multi-chip communications. The wireless nature of these links provides flexibility in chip placement and thermal expansion management that rigid electrical connectors cannot match.
Practical implementation faces significant challenges including power consumption of terahertz transceivers, thermal management of high-power-density chips, and co-design of antennas with chip metallization and packaging structures. Maintaining link reliability in the presence of thermal gradients, mechanical vibrations, and electromagnetic interference from other chip functions requires robust system design. Nonetheless, demonstration systems have shown the feasibility of multi-gigabit chip-to-chip terahertz links, and continued advances in integrated circuit technology may make this approach viable for future high-performance computing applications, particularly in specialized systems where the benefits justify the additional complexity.
Material Characterization
Terahertz spectroscopy provides powerful capabilities for material characterization, exploiting the fact that many materials exhibit distinctive absorption, transmission, and reflection characteristics at terahertz frequencies. Time-domain terahertz spectroscopy measures the complete electric field of terahertz pulses, both amplitude and phase, allowing extraction of complex refractive index and absorption coefficient as functions of frequency. This spectroscopic information reveals molecular vibrations, crystal structures, and electronic properties that are invisible to other characterization techniques.
Pharmaceutical industry applications include polymorphism detection, where different crystal forms of the same drug molecule exhibit distinct terahertz spectra, ensuring that correct and stable forms are manufactured. Coating thickness measurements with terahertz time-domain systems provide non-contact, non-destructive characterization of thin films on various substrates. Semiconductor industry applications characterize carrier density, mobility, and other electronic properties of materials using terahertz transmission or reflection measurements, complementing electrical and optical characterization methods.
Art conservation and archaeology leverage terahertz imaging to examine paintings, manuscripts, and artifacts, revealing under-drawings, detecting alterations, and identifying pigments without damaging precious works. Food industry applications assess moisture content, fat distribution, and detect foreign objects in packaged foods. Polymer and composite characterization uses terahertz techniques to measure thickness, detect voids and delaminations, and monitor curing processes. The non-destructive, non-contact nature of terahertz measurements makes them particularly valuable for quality control in manufacturing processes where traditional destructive testing is impractical or where contact-based measurements might damage products.
Regulatory Considerations and Spectrum Allocation
Regulatory frameworks for terahertz communications are still evolving as the technology matures and potential applications become clearer. International regulatory bodies including the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) have begun allocating portions of the terahertz spectrum for specific services, balancing communication needs with passive services like radio astronomy and earth remote sensing that also use these frequencies. The World Radiocommunication Conference has addressed terahertz allocations, establishing frameworks for both licensed and unlicensed operation in various bands.
Many jurisdictions are adopting light-licensing or unlicensed approaches for short-range terahertz communications, recognizing that the inherently limited range and high atmospheric absorption minimize interference concerns. Regulatory technical standards specify power limits, emission masks, and coexistence mechanisms to ensure that terahertz systems operate without causing harmful interference to other services. Safety regulations address exposure limits for terahertz radiation, though the non-ionizing nature and limited penetration depth in biological tissues result in safety thresholds generally higher than achievable with current technology.
Standardization efforts by organizations including IEEE, ETSI, and industry consortia are developing technical standards for terahertz communications, defining physical layer specifications, protocol stacks, and interoperability requirements. These standards will enable multi-vendor ecosystems and reduce deployment costs through economies of scale. Export controls and security considerations may affect some terahertz technologies, particularly those with dual-use potential in sensing and imaging applications. As terahertz communications transition from research to commercial deployment, regulatory frameworks will continue evolving to accommodate new use cases while protecting existing services and ensuring safe operation.
Challenges and Future Directions
Despite significant progress, terahertz communications face several fundamental challenges that must be addressed for widespread deployment. Power efficiency of terahertz sources and detectors remains a critical concern, particularly for mobile and battery-powered applications. Most current terahertz devices exhibit lower efficiency than their microwave or optical counterparts, requiring continued advances in device physics and circuit design. Atmospheric absorption, while manageable for short-range links, fundamentally limits the range of terahertz systems and creates dependencies on environmental conditions that must be addressed through adaptive techniques or hybrid systems.
Integration and packaging of terahertz systems present ongoing challenges. Connecting high-frequency circuits, antennas, and interface electronics while minimizing losses and maintaining electromagnetic compatibility requires advanced packaging solutions. Cost reduction through higher volume manufacturing and standardization is essential for commercial viability beyond specialized applications. The lack of commercial off-the-shelf components forces many researchers and developers to create custom solutions, slowing development and increasing costs.
Future research directions include development of room-temperature, high-power terahertz sources; large-format detector arrays for imaging; integration with artificial intelligence for adaptive modulation and beam steering; and exploitation of intelligent reflecting surfaces to overcome line-of-sight limitations. Convergence with other technologies—including millimeter-wave 5G/6G systems, free-space optical communications, and photonic integrated circuits—may enable hybrid systems that combine the advantages of multiple approaches. As applications mature and drive technology development, terahertz communications is poised to transition from research laboratories to practical deployment in data centers, wireless backhaul, chip interconnects, and specialized high-bandwidth applications, opening new frontiers in wireless communications and sensing.
Related Topics
- Emerging Communication Technologies - Parent category covering next-generation wireless systems
- Communication Electronics - Broader category of communication systems and technologies
- EMC and EMI - Fundamental principles governing wave propagation
- Semiconductor Devices - Device physics underlying terahertz sources and detectors
- Optoelectronics - Photonic techniques used in terahertz generation
- Antenna Design - Principles of antenna engineering applied to terahertz frequencies
Further Learning
To deepen your understanding of terahertz communications, explore electromagnetic propagation at millimeter and submillimeter wavelengths, study advanced semiconductor device physics, and investigate signal processing techniques for ultra-wideband communications. Practical experience with microwave and millimeter-wave systems provides valuable background for understanding terahertz challenges. Stay current with research literature from conferences like the International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter, and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz) and journals covering photonics, microwave theory, and wireless communications. Understanding both electronic and photonic approaches to terahertz technology provides comprehensive perspective on this interdisciplinary field.