Electronics Guide

Through-Hole and Mixed Assembly

Through-hole and mixed assembly technologies represent the traditional foundation of electronics manufacturing while continuing to serve critical roles in modern production. Unlike surface-mount technology where components sit on the board surface, through-hole assembly involves inserting component leads through holes drilled in the printed circuit board, creating mechanical connections that are then soldered. Mixed assembly combines both through-hole and surface-mount technologies on the same board, leveraging the advantages of each approach.

While surface-mount technology dominates modern electronics for its miniaturization and automation benefits, through-hole assembly remains essential for components requiring high mechanical strength, high current capacity, frequent connections and disconnections, or easy field replacement. Applications ranging from power supplies and industrial controls to automotive electronics and aerospace systems continue to rely on through-hole and mixed assembly approaches for their unique advantages in reliability, durability, and serviceability.

Through-Hole Component Types

Axial Components

Axial components feature leads extending from both ends of the component body along a single axis. Common examples include resistors, diodes, some capacitors, and fuses. These components are typically inserted using automated axial insertion machines that clinch and cut the leads to the appropriate length.

The insertion process for axial components involves several steps: component orientation verification, lead forming to match the hole spacing, insertion through the board holes, lead clinching on the bottom side to hold the component in place, and lead trimming to the proper length for soldering. Modern axial insertion equipment can place thousands of components per hour with high accuracy and repeatability.

Design considerations for axial components include appropriate hole spacing (typically standardized at intervals like 0.3 inches, 0.4 inches, or 0.5 inches), adequate clearance for the component body above the board surface, and proper orientation for polarized components like diodes and electrolytic capacitors. The spacing between the component body and board surface should allow for thermal expansion, cleaning solutions to flow through, and inspection access.

Radial Components

Radial components have both leads emerging from the same side of the component body, perpendicular to the component's main axis. Electrolytic capacitors, ceramic disc capacitors, and some inductors commonly use radial lead configurations. These components stand perpendicular to the board surface, requiring different insertion techniques than axial components.

Radial insertion machines must accommodate varying lead spacing and component heights. The insertion process includes lead preparation, vertical insertion through holes, and retention of the component against the board surface until soldering. Some radial components feature non-standard lead spacing, requiring manual insertion or specialized tooling.

When designing for radial components, engineers must consider the component height and ensure adequate clearance for neighboring components and any enclosures. Polarized radial components require clear polarity marking on both the component and the PCB silkscreen. The hole spacing should match standard lead configurations when possible to facilitate automated assembly.

Dual In-Line Package (DIP) Components

DIP components feature two parallel rows of leads and include integrated circuits, resistor networks, and various other components. These packages range from narrow DIP configurations with 0.3-inch row spacing to wider versions with 0.6-inch or greater spacing. DIP insertion requires precise alignment of multiple pins simultaneously.

Automated DIP insertion machines use tooling specific to each package size and lead count. The insertion process must ensure all leads enter their respective holes without bending, which requires high mechanical precision. Some high-reliability applications use DIP sockets instead of direct soldering, allowing component replacement without desoldering.

Design considerations for DIP components include proper orientation marking (usually a notch or dot indicating pin 1), adequate spacing from adjacent components for heat dissipation, and consideration of socket height if sockets are used. High-speed digital circuits using DIP packages require careful attention to lead inductance and signal integrity.

Odd-Form Components

Odd-form components include any through-hole parts that don't fit standard axial, radial, or DIP categories. Examples include transformers, large inductors, connectors, terminal blocks, potentiometers, switches, and specialized components with unique lead configurations. These components typically require manual insertion or specialized custom tooling.

The challenges of odd-form components include non-standard lead patterns, large component bodies, varying heights, heavy weight requiring mechanical support, and unique orientation requirements. Manual assembly operators must be trained on proper insertion techniques for each component type, including appropriate force application to avoid damage.

Documentation for odd-form components should include detailed assembly drawings showing component orientation, any special insertion tools required, torque specifications for mounting hardware, and inspection criteria. Some odd-form components may require additional mechanical fastening beyond solder joints to provide structural support.

Through-Hole Soldering Processes

Wave Soldering

Wave soldering is the traditional automated soldering process for through-hole assemblies. The process involves passing the bottom of a populated PCB over a continuously flowing wave of molten solder. The wave contacts the exposed leads and pads, creating solder joints as the board exits the wave and the solder solidifies.

The wave soldering process typically includes several stages: flux application to clean and prepare surfaces, preheating to bring the assembly to a controlled temperature, contact with the solder wave for joint formation, and cooling. Modern wave soldering machines carefully control the solder temperature (typically 240-260°C for tin-lead solder, higher for lead-free), wave dynamics, conveyor speed, and thermal profile.

Successful wave soldering requires proper board design including adequate solder pad sizes, appropriate hole-to-lead clearance (typically 0.15-0.25mm diametral clearance), thermal reliefs on ground plane connections, and component placement that avoids shadowing. Components must be positioned to prevent solder bridging, and sensitive components should be placed away from areas of maximum heat exposure.

Common wave soldering defects include solder bridges between adjacent pads, insufficient solder fill in plated-through holes, icicles or solder spikes on leads, and thermal damage to components. Process optimization addresses these issues through adjustment of flux type and application, preheat profile, wave characteristics, and board conveyor angle.

Selective Soldering

Selective soldering applies molten solder to specific locations on a PCB rather than the entire bottom surface. This technology enables through-hole soldering on boards that also contain temperature-sensitive surface-mount components or areas that must remain solder-free. Selective soldering uses a small, programmable solder wave or fountain that moves to each soldering location.

The selective soldering process involves programming the machine with the coordinates of each through-hole location requiring soldering. The system typically includes selective flux application, localized preheating, and precise solder application using a miniature wave, fountain, or drag soldering technique. The small solder contact area minimizes thermal stress on the board and adjacent components.

Applications for selective soldering include mixed-technology boards where surface-mount components cannot withstand wave soldering temperatures, boards with bottom-side SMT components, assemblies requiring different solder alloys in different areas, and products where certain areas must remain flux-free. The process offers excellent flexibility but operates at lower throughput than wave soldering.

Design considerations for selective soldering include adequate spacing between through-hole components to allow nozzle access, consistent board thickness and flatness for reliable solder contact, and thermal mass balance to ensure proper heat transfer. The selective soldering program must be validated to ensure complete joint formation without damaging nearby components.

Manual Soldering

Manual soldering remains essential for prototype assembly, rework, repair, and production of low-volume or highly complex assemblies. Skilled technicians use temperature-controlled soldering irons to create individual solder joints, allowing precise control and the ability to handle unique situations that automated equipment cannot accommodate.

Proper manual soldering technique involves cleaning the surfaces to be joined, applying flux if not present in the solder, heating the joint area with the iron tip, feeding solder into the heated joint (not onto the iron), allowing the solder to flow and wet both surfaces, and removing heat while holding the joint steady until the solder solidifies. The entire process typically takes 2-4 seconds per joint to avoid thermal damage.

Temperature selection for manual soldering depends on the solder alloy, joint thermal mass, and component sensitivity. Typical settings range from 315-370°C for tin-lead solder and 370-425°C for lead-free alloys. The iron tip should be sized appropriately for the joint, with larger tips for high thermal mass joints and smaller tips for delicate work. Regular tip cleaning and tinning maintains heat transfer efficiency.

Quality manual soldering produces joints with smooth, concave fillets showing complete wetting of the pad and lead. Common defects include cold solder joints from insufficient heat, disturbed joints from movement during cooling, excessive solder creating convex joints, insufficient solder leaving gaps, and thermal damage from prolonged heating. Proper training, appropriate tools, and good lighting enable consistent quality manual soldering.

Mixed Assembly Technologies

Pin-in-Paste Technology

Pin-in-paste (PIP) technology allows through-hole components to be soldered using the same reflow process as surface-mount components, eliminating the need for separate wave or selective soldering operations. This approach involves printing solder paste on the through-hole pads, inserting the through-hole component leads, and reflowing the entire assembly in a standard SMT reflow oven.

The process requires careful attention to several factors: adequate solder paste volume to fill the plated-through holes after reflow, paste formulation designed for pin-in-paste applications with appropriate metal content and flux activity, proper hole size allowing paste to remain in the hole during component insertion, and reflow profile providing sufficient time for paste to flow through the hole and form reliable joints.

Design guidelines for pin-in-paste include using smaller hole sizes (typically 0.05-0.15mm larger than the lead diameter rather than the standard 0.15-0.25mm), ensuring adequate pad area around the hole for paste deposition, applying paste to both top and bottom pads when possible, and limiting the technique to components with relatively small leads and low thermal mass. Component lead finish affects paste wetting and joint formation.

Advantages of pin-in-paste include single-sided assembly enabling bottom-side SMT components, reduced process steps and equipment requirements, improved throughput for mixed assemblies, and consistent thermal exposure for all components. Limitations include restrictions on component size and weight, potential for insufficient solder fill in larger holes, and difficulties with components having long or non-uniform leads.

Intrusive Reflow

Intrusive reflow soldering represents an advanced variation of pin-in-paste technology, using specialized solder paste formulations and process parameters to achieve reliable through-hole joints via reflow. This technique extends PIP capabilities to larger components and deeper holes through optimized paste chemistry and deposition strategies.

Intrusive reflow pastes feature higher metal content (often 92-95% by weight compared to standard 88-90%), specialized flux systems promoting enhanced wetting and capillary flow, and particle size distributions optimized for through-hole filling. The paste must exhibit minimal slump during preheat while achieving sufficient fluidity during peak reflow to fill the hole via capillary action.

Process optimization for intrusive reflow includes extended soak times allowing flux activation and gas escape, controlled heating rates preventing paste outgassing from pushing solder away from holes, peak temperatures and times ensuring complete alloy melting and flow, and sometimes multiple reflow passes for components with high thermal mass or deep holes.

Applications benefiting from intrusive reflow include compact mixed-technology assemblies where traditional wave soldering isn't feasible, products requiring bottom-side SMT components, high-reliability applications where consistent thermal profiles are critical, and designs where process simplification justifies the engineering effort. The technique requires thorough validation and may need component-specific process recipes.

Press-Fit Technology

Press-fit technology creates reliable electrical and mechanical connections by pressing specially designed component leads or pins into plated-through holes without soldering. The interference fit between the compliant pin and the hole barrel creates gas-tight contact pressure, establishing both electrical conductivity and mechanical retention.

Press-fit pins feature specific geometries creating controlled interference with the hole barrel. Common designs include compliant pins with spring sections that compress during insertion, solid pins with slightly oversized sections creating interference, and eye-of-the-needle designs with split sections. The pin material, typically copper alloy or specialized contact materials, must provide appropriate elasticity and long-term contact stability.

The press-fit process uses precision tooling to apply controlled force, inserting pins perpendicular to the board surface without damaging the plated-through hole or board laminate. Process monitoring tracks insertion force curves, detecting anomalies indicating problems like undersized holes, oversized pins, board delamination, or missing holes. Proper insertion produces characteristic force signatures validated during process development.

Applications for press-fit technology include backplanes and high-speed interconnects, power distribution systems, connectors requiring field replacement or reconfiguration, high-reliability systems where solder joint integrity concerns exist, and assemblies where soldering heat would damage components or materials. The technology offers excellent long-term reliability, eliminates thermal stress during assembly, enables rework, and simplifies automated assembly of heavy connectors.

Terminal Blocks and Connectors

Terminal blocks and connectors in through-hole format provide field-wirable connections for power, signals, and input/output interfaces. These components range from simple screw terminals for wire connection to complex multi-pin connectors for system integration. Their mechanical robustness and ease of field wiring make them essential for many industrial and consumer applications.

Terminal block assembly considerations include mounting orientation for accessible wire entry, mechanical support for heavy connectors using mounting holes or brackets, strain relief for wiring, proper torque specifications for screw terminals, and consideration of wire gauges and types the terminal will accommodate. Some designs use combination mounting with both solder joints and mechanical fasteners for enhanced reliability.

Connector assembly must address proper orientation and keying to prevent incorrect mating, retention force ensuring connectors remain mated during vibration and handling, adequate clearance for connector housing and mating connector or cable, and consideration of insertion and extraction forces. High-reliability applications may specify specific connector brands and styles with proven performance characteristics.

Testing and validation of terminal blocks and connectors includes verification of proper mounting and retention, contact resistance measurements, pull testing of wire terminations, mating and unmating force testing, and environmental testing under relevant temperature, humidity, and vibration conditions. Documentation should specify acceptable wire types, stripping lengths, and any special termination requirements.

Mixed Technology Assembly Strategies

Process Flow Planning

Mixed technology assemblies require careful process flow planning to optimize quality, efficiency, and cost. The sequence of assembly operations significantly impacts the final result, with considerations including thermal exposure management, component accessibility, handling constraints, and process capability.

Common process flow approaches include top-side SMT followed by through-hole assembly (traditional approach minimizing reflow exposure for through-hole components), double-sided SMT followed by selective through-hole soldering (maximizing SMT component density), pin-in-paste integration allowing single reflow process for both technologies, and staged assembly with multiple passes through different processes.

Process flow decision factors include component temperature ratings and thermal mass, solder alloy compatibility requirements, geometric constraints on solder application, quality and inspection requirements at different stages, cost and throughput targets, and available equipment and capabilities. Computer-aided assembly planning tools can model alternative flows and predict outcomes.

Validation of the chosen process flow involves building sample assemblies, monitoring critical parameters at each stage, performing cross-sectional analysis of solder joints, conducting thermal profiling throughout all heating processes, testing electrical functionality, and assessing long-term reliability through accelerated life testing. Process documentation captures proven parameters and identifies critical control points.

Design for Mixed Assembly

Designing products for mixed assembly requires understanding both surface-mount and through-hole manufacturing constraints while optimizing for the specific combination of technologies employed. Effective design choices simplify manufacturing, improve quality, and reduce costs.

Component placement strategies for mixed assemblies include grouping components by technology type when possible to facilitate process optimization, maintaining adequate spacing for tooling access, placing through-hole components to avoid shadowing during wave soldering, positioning temperature-sensitive components away from high-heat process areas, and considering assembly sequence in placement decisions.

Pad and hole design must accommodate the specific soldering processes employed. Through-hole pads for wave soldering require adequate size and thermal relief to prevent tombstoning or lifting while ensuring good solder fill. Pin-in-paste applications need optimized hole sizes and pad areas for paste deposition. Mixed assemblies may need custom pad designs balancing different process requirements.

Board material and construction choices impact mixed assembly success. Adequate thermal mass and conductivity distribution prevents warping during reflow while supporting wave soldering. Board thickness affects press-fit insertion forces and solder fill in through-holes. Material selection must consider the maximum thermal exposure from all processes while maintaining dimensional stability and electrical properties.

Quality and Inspection

Quality assurance for mixed assemblies must address the unique characteristics of each technology while ensuring overall product integrity. Inspection strategies combine automated optical inspection (AOI), X-ray inspection, in-circuit testing, and functional testing tailored to the specific assembly.

Through-hole inspection typically focuses on solder fill in plated-through holes, fillet quality on the top side, absence of bridging and icicles, proper component orientation and seating, and lead trimming quality. Visual inspection remains important for through-hole joints, as automated optical inspection may have limitations accessing through-hole solder joints from the bottom side.

Mixed assembly inspection must occur at appropriate stages in the process flow. Inspecting SMT components before through-hole assembly allows rework without disturbing through-hole components. In-process inspection catches defects early when correction is easier and less expensive. Final inspection verifies the cumulative result of all processes.

Common defects in mixed assemblies include SMT components displaced during through-hole processing, thermal damage from multiple heating cycles, solder contamination between processes, mechanical stress from handling, and process interactions like flux residue from wave soldering affecting selective soldering. Understanding these failure modes enables preventive process design and effective inspection strategies.

Cost Optimization

Mixed assembly cost optimization requires balancing the economics of different technologies and processes. While pure SMT assembly generally offers the lowest per-unit cost, many applications require through-hole components for specific functions, necessitating cost-effective mixed assembly strategies.

Cost factors include equipment requirements and depreciation, process yield and rework costs, material costs for different component types and solder alloys, labor content for manual operations, throughput and cycle time, and test and inspection costs. Minimizing the number of different processes while maintaining quality generally reduces total cost.

Strategies for cost reduction include maximizing use of pin-in-paste or intrusive reflow to eliminate separate through-hole soldering, standardizing component types and packages to simplify procurement and inventory, designing for automated assembly wherever feasible, optimizing panel utilization and assembly sequence, and implementing robust processes reducing rework requirements.

The optimal cost structure depends on production volume, product complexity, quality requirements, and available manufacturing capabilities. Low-volume production may justify more manual assembly, while high-volume production demands maximum automation. Life-cycle cost analysis should consider field reliability, serviceability, and end-of-life recycling in addition to manufacturing costs.

Advanced Considerations

High-Reliability Applications

High-reliability applications in aerospace, military, medical, and critical industrial systems place special demands on through-hole and mixed assembly. These applications require proven processes, rigorous quality control, traceability, and often certification to industry standards like IPC-A-610 Class 3.

Process controls for high-reliability assembly include statistical process control monitoring critical parameters, periodic process capability studies, strict material lot control and traceability, environmental controls for temperature and humidity, contamination prevention, and comprehensive operator training and certification. Equipment maintenance schedules ensure consistent process performance.

Inspection requirements typically exceed commercial standards, with 100% visual inspection, automated X-ray inspection of all solder joints, electrical testing verifying all connections, and destructive testing of sample boards for process validation. Documentation requirements include complete assembly records, material certifications, process parameter logs, and inspection results.

Design requirements for high-reliability applications often mandate conformal coating or encapsulation for environmental protection, specific component derating factors, redundant connections for critical signals, stress relief for mechanically loaded solder joints, and proven component types with established reliability data. Failure mode effects analysis (FMEA) guides design and process decisions.

Lead-Free Considerations

Lead-free soldering presents specific challenges for through-hole and mixed assembly due to higher melting temperatures, different wetting characteristics, and increased thermal stress on components and boards. Successfully implementing lead-free processes requires attention to materials, processes, and design.

Common lead-free alloys for through-hole assembly include SAC305 (96.5% tin, 3% silver, 0.5% copper) and SAC405, though various alternatives exist for specific requirements. These alloys typically melt around 217-220°C, requiring process temperatures 30-40°C higher than tin-lead solder. The higher temperatures demand component and board materials capable of withstanding increased thermal stress.

Wave soldering with lead-free alloys requires careful process optimization addressing slower wetting speeds, increased dross formation, higher thermal demand, and more brittle solder joints. Process improvements include higher preheat temperatures, slower conveyor speeds, optimized flux selection, inert atmosphere or nitrogen blanketing, and regular dross removal. Board finishes must be compatible with lead-free soldering temperatures and alloys.

Mixed assembly with lead-free processes faces challenges from the cumulative thermal exposure during multiple heating cycles. Components must withstand multiple exposures to temperatures exceeding 240°C. Board materials require higher glass transition temperatures and thermal stability. Design thermal analysis ensures all components and board areas survive the complete process sequence without degradation.

Rework and Repair

Through-hole component rework and repair require specialized skills and techniques to remove and replace components without damaging the board or neighboring components. Proper rework procedures restore the assembly to full functionality and reliability.

Through-hole component removal typically uses one of several methods: desoldering with solder wick to remove solder and pull components, vacuum desoldering to extract solder while heating the joint, hot air reflow with mechanical extraction for surface-accessible components, or selective heating tools for specific components. The method chosen depends on component type, board access, and operator skill.

Multi-pin component removal presents particular challenges due to the need to simultaneously heat all pins while avoiding thermal damage. Specialized tools including desoldering stations with heated tips and vacuum extraction, preheating stations bringing the board to controlled temperature, and selective heating heads enable reliable removal of DIP packages, connectors, and other multi-pin components.

Component installation during rework follows the same principles as original assembly but requires additional care. Hole cleaning ensures solder acceptance, component alignment must be precise without automatic insertion equipment, soldering parameters must match the original process, and post-rework inspection verifies proper joint formation and component orientation. Rework documentation tracks any component replacements and process deviations for traceability.

Environmental and Regulatory Compliance

Through-hole and mixed assembly processes must comply with environmental regulations, occupational safety requirements, and product regulations applicable to the manufacturing location and product destination markets. Compliance planning should begin during design and process development.

The European Union's RoHS (Restriction of Hazardous Substances) directive limits lead and other materials in electronic products, driving adoption of lead-free soldering in most commercial electronics. REACH regulation controls chemicals used in manufacturing. Similar regulations exist in other regions, requiring manufacturers to maintain material compliance documentation and select appropriate processes and materials.

Flux residues from soldering processes raise environmental and product concerns. No-clean flux formulations minimize cleaning requirements, reducing chemical usage and waste generation. When cleaning is required, modern processes use water-based or biodegradable cleaning agents rather than ozone-depleting solvents. Waste management for solder dross, cleaning solutions, and failed boards must follow environmental regulations.

Worker safety in through-hole assembly addresses fume extraction from soldering operations, handling of heated equipment and materials, ergonomic design of assembly stations, and protection from chemical exposure during cleaning operations. Proper training, protective equipment, and engineering controls ensure a safe work environment while maintaining productivity and quality.

Conclusion

Through-hole and mixed assembly technologies continue to serve essential roles in modern electronics manufacturing despite the dominance of surface-mount technology in many applications. The mechanical strength, high current capacity, field replaceability, and ease of visual inspection offered by through-hole components make them irreplaceable for many product categories.

Success with through-hole and mixed assembly requires understanding the diverse component types and their assembly requirements, mastering both automated and manual soldering processes, optimizing process flows for mixed technology products, and implementing appropriate quality and inspection strategies. Design decisions fundamentally impact manufacturing success, making collaboration between design and manufacturing essential.

As electronics products continue to evolve, through-hole and mixed assembly approaches adapt with innovations like pin-in-paste technology, advanced selective soldering, and press-fit connections. These developments expand the capabilities of traditional technologies while maintaining their fundamental advantages. Engineers who understand both traditional through-hole assembly and modern surface-mount technology can design and manufacture products optimally leveraging the strengths of each approach, creating reliable, manufacturable, and cost-effective electronic assemblies.